My mother-in-law was laughing because she couldn’t believe that her friend didn’t know what paprika was made of.
I was too embarrassed to admit that I didn’t know either. I stayed quiet, nodding along, pretending I was in on the joke.
Later that night, curiosity got the best of me. I pulled out my phone and typed: “What is paprika made of?”
The answer was simple: paprika is made from dried and ground red peppers.
I felt relieved, but also foolish. Something so basic, and I hadn’t known. I laughed at myself quietly—until I realized something strange.
The next morning, I overheard my mother-in-law on the phone. Her tone was sharp, hushed. She said, “Don’t you dare tell her the truth. She thinks paprika is just peppers.”
Also Read : Large bear breaks into ice cream shop, attracted to straw-bear-y flavor
I froze. What truth?
When she hung up, I confronted her. She smiled in that cold way of hers and said, “Curiosity can be dangerous, dear. Some recipes aren’t meant to be uncovered.”
Her words sent a chill through me. That night, I couldn’t sleep. I snuck into her pantry, searching through jars and containers. And that’s when I found it—one jar labeled “Paprika,” but inside wasn’t powder. It was small, dried fragments of something I couldn’t recognize.
It didn’t look like peppers at all.
I decided to take a bit in a bag and bring it to a friend of mine who worked in a lab. A few days later, she called me, her voice trembling. “You need to come in. Now.”
When I arrived, she looked pale. “This isn’t paprika,” she said quietly. “It’s bone. Ground human bone mixed with spices.”
My stomach turned to ice.
That evening, I went home, pretending everything was normal. My mother-in-law was at the stove, humming while she stirred a pot of stew. I noticed the familiar jar of “paprika” sitting beside her.
She glanced at me and smiled. “Dinner will be ready soon.”
My hands shook. “Where… where do you get your paprika?” I asked.
Her smile widened, almost proud. “It’s a family recipe. Passed down for generations. We use what others won’t. It binds us together.”
I felt sick. My mind raced with the memory of every meal I had eaten at her table. Every dish she had insisted I try.
She must have seen the horror in my face because her eyes narrowed. “You shouldn’t have gone snooping.”
At that moment, Samuel—my husband—walked in. He looked between us, confused. “What’s going on?”
Before I could speak, my mother-in-law said sweetly, “She found out about our tradition.”
Our. Tradition.
Samuel’s expression didn’t change. He didn’t look shocked. He didn’t look horrified. He simply nodded.
And that’s when I realized the truth was much darker than I had ever imagined. This wasn’t just her secret. It was theirs. A family secret—one they intended for me to become part of.
