A baby’s name is a deeply personal choice, often shaped by loved ones, celebrities, or fictional characters. One mother recently faced backlash after naming her twin boys Noel and Liam, inspired by the Gallagher brothers from the band Oasis.

As a lifelong fan, she viewed the names as a heartfelt tribute. However, her choice has drawn unexpected criticism, prompting her to share her frustration on the parenting forum Mumsnet.

“Judged for my kids’ names?!,” she wrote, explaining her admiration for Oasis. What she saw as a meaningful gesture was dismissed by others as odd or laughable.

Her post received more than 200 comments, reflecting a wide range of opinions. Some users offered support, noting that Noel and Liam are fairly mainstream names. “It’s not like the name is Ringo-esque or anything,” one commenter pointed out.

Others were less kind. One person wrote, “I’m not surprised they laugh really,” suggesting that the decision seemed unusual. These contrasting reactions highlight how divisive baby name choices can be.

Supporters emphasized that Liam and Noel are not only linked to Oasis but are also established names with cultural history beyond the band. For them, the criticism seemed unnecessary.

Still, as one user wisely observed, “Names are a bit of a polarizing thing anyway, and it doesn’t really matter what anyone else thinks.” This sentiment captured the heart of the debate: naming is ultimately about meaning for the parents.

The mother’s story is a reminder that every name carries a backstory. For her, Noel and Liam symbolize not just favorite musicians but also a piece of her identity and passions. Criticism may come, but love and intention are what truly matter.